{ "recommended_method": "Open3D B gated by Open3D-small_gicp cross-backend agreement", "selection_is_X_independent": true, "second_batch_role": "estimation (dense RTK)", "first_batch_role": "auxiliary check only (sparse RTK)", "consensus": { "translation_m": [ 1.2977596922478565, -6.733076264476427e-05, 0.7204978345266887 ], "rotation_rpy_deg_xyz": [ -0.7851511464150316, 1.2026608220810453, -0.835510052785851 ], "estimation": { "pairs": 39, "translation_m": { "rms": 0.07984780651249465, "median": 0.05392926910429046, "p90": 0.11822807898946641, "p95": 0.14420733112402187, "max": 0.2330103519747209 }, "rotation_deg": { "rms": 0.961176171904301, "median": 0.8002960897011372, "p90": 1.422624767604584, "p95": 1.4793113785217964, "max": 1.7237415928660533 }, "per_pair": [ { "pair_index": 0, "translation_m": 0.1353760421849012, "rotation_deg": 0.5166365681634405 }, { "pair_index": 1, "translation_m": 0.11487543918383647, "rotation_deg": 0.5717221816616095 }, { "pair_index": 2, "translation_m": 0.06210064976174764, "rotation_deg": 0.4402983357286552 }, { "pair_index": 3, "translation_m": 0.054355548674489614, "rotation_deg": 0.5821611725015269 }, { "pair_index": 4, "translation_m": 0.02391657882546618, "rotation_deg": 0.32738975448002894 }, { "pair_index": 5, "translation_m": 0.07775220171630512, "rotation_deg": 0.8706732532310371 }, { "pair_index": 6, "translation_m": 0.06265840922697155, "rotation_deg": 0.8002960897011372 }, { "pair_index": 7, "translation_m": 0.09282561040685418, "rotation_deg": 1.0484294819479303 }, { "pair_index": 8, "translation_m": 0.034474807960716856, "rotation_deg": 0.40941928556312257 }, { "pair_index": 9, "translation_m": 0.13163863821198593, "rotation_deg": 1.1065820279922887 }, { "pair_index": 10, "translation_m": 0.0018609877360485794, "rotation_deg": 0.6081452332544832 }, { "pair_index": 11, "translation_m": 0.06488404028756532, "rotation_deg": 0.05192051717362457 }, { "pair_index": 12, "translation_m": 0.1147488321233841, "rotation_deg": 0.9937108406424444 }, { "pair_index": 13, "translation_m": 0.05392926910429046, "rotation_deg": 0.9700546737541248 }, { "pair_index": 14, "translation_m": 0.02302185790244543, "rotation_deg": 1.6149869587730064 }, { "pair_index": 15, "translation_m": 0.2330103519747209, "rotation_deg": 0.5939965715201481 }, { "pair_index": 16, "translation_m": 0.2236889315761065, "rotation_deg": 1.1151964340680336 }, { "pair_index": 17, "translation_m": 0.04090994021171706, "rotation_deg": 0.7785618518380144 }, { "pair_index": 18, "translation_m": 0.054652520003134704, "rotation_deg": 1.124375763416717 }, { "pair_index": 19, "translation_m": 0.04547500551567543, "rotation_deg": 0.6556954445211121 }, { "pair_index": 20, "translation_m": 0.02484690940972022, "rotation_deg": 1.7237415928660533 }, { "pair_index": 21, "translation_m": 0.056832852413462566, "rotation_deg": 0.5831473606925555 }, { "pair_index": 22, "translation_m": 0.03998842216950218, "rotation_deg": 1.124691549503354 }, { "pair_index": 23, "translation_m": 0.052224143195848054, "rotation_deg": 1.1184574012171749 }, { "pair_index": 24, "translation_m": 0.06305629062353875, "rotation_deg": 0.5252019728243343 }, { "pair_index": 25, "translation_m": 0.0552093328283033, "rotation_deg": 0.08705258513790126 }, { "pair_index": 26, "translation_m": 0.08502281683725502, "rotation_deg": 0.6459827373704314 }, { "pair_index": 27, "translation_m": 0.03727269737723399, "rotation_deg": 0.7631660358041192 }, { "pair_index": 28, "translation_m": 0.04543722819346571, "rotation_deg": 1.4218618784137362 }, { "pair_index": 29, "translation_m": 0.02559982081388642, "rotation_deg": 1.388947601285772 }, { "pair_index": 30, "translation_m": 0.01827234061769129, "rotation_deg": 1.206866980510853 }, { "pair_index": 31, "translation_m": 0.06863732394647468, "rotation_deg": 1.4642363140494394 }, { "pair_index": 32, "translation_m": 0.04770629220585725, "rotation_deg": 0.6244903967618446 }, { "pair_index": 33, "translation_m": 0.027074935362624366, "rotation_deg": 1.3688430767407767 }, { "pair_index": 34, "translation_m": 0.03301156138156032, "rotation_deg": 1.4256763243679755 }, { "pair_index": 35, "translation_m": 0.054240160043693975, "rotation_deg": 0.6486412679040612 }, { "pair_index": 36, "translation_m": 0.021992835671895014, "rotation_deg": 0.23769553016909395 }, { "pair_index": 37, "translation_m": 0.031890552923517286, "rotation_deg": 1.0832171246083164 }, { "pair_index": 38, "translation_m": 0.025286131886091672, "rotation_deg": 1.2215923174512224 } ] }, "bootstrap_std": [ 0.003223574650236103, 0.003334649335095665, 0.0016858977028131694, 0.0980155224808408, 0.07461769310738842, 0.11886090357304822 ], "batch1_auxiliary": { "pairs": 22, "translation_m": { "rms": 0.06067269746244947, "median": 0.042680679229823305, "p90": 0.090942947259565, "p95": 0.10135707648063859, "max": 0.14643003383767556 }, "rotation_deg": { "rms": 1.002984942285067, "median": 0.707406938077333, "p90": 1.573355332434981, "p95": 1.7757584051966382, "max": 1.8710372365314285 }, "per_pair": [ { "pair_index": 0, "translation_m": 0.048343805321803004, "rotation_deg": 0.6668376546913104, "i": 0, "j": 3 }, { "pair_index": 1, "translation_m": 0.0423483041362295, "rotation_deg": 1.7859688557628564, "i": 1, "j": 2 }, { "pair_index": 2, "translation_m": 0.02300615185240312, "rotation_deg": 1.8710372365314285, "i": 2, "j": 3 }, { "pair_index": 3, "translation_m": 0.09155252198785023, "rotation_deg": 0.6733340854508988, "i": 3, "j": 4 }, { "pair_index": 4, "translation_m": 0.03158045213093479, "rotation_deg": 0.2310116592109763, "i": 3, "j": 5 }, { "pair_index": 5, "translation_m": 0.07825296974670955, "rotation_deg": 0.7403656481818025, "i": 4, "j": 5 }, { "pair_index": 6, "translation_m": 0.03623050776977002, "rotation_deg": 0.29976499205053747, "i": 5, "j": 6 }, { "pair_index": 7, "translation_m": 0.017322045818086197, "rotation_deg": 1.0428116209013618, "i": 6, "j": 7 }, { "pair_index": 8, "translation_m": 0.037890995883582496, "rotation_deg": 0.5003524050137443, "i": 6, "j": 9 }, { "pair_index": 9, "translation_m": 0.055811972906268326, "rotation_deg": 0.9711899476368479, "i": 11, "j": 12 }, { "pair_index": 10, "translation_m": 0.10187310566446957, "rotation_deg": 0.48973592009907335, "i": 17, "j": 18 }, { "pair_index": 11, "translation_m": 0.0304808468879537, "rotation_deg": 1.3239848803794854, "i": 20, "j": 21 }, { "pair_index": 12, "translation_m": 0.04462456608967399, "rotation_deg": 0.2812977599385038, "i": 20, "j": 22 }, { "pair_index": 13, "translation_m": 0.03611683783839059, "rotation_deg": 0.7096084761069892, "i": 20, "j": 23 }, { "pair_index": 14, "translation_m": 0.07267248449673575, "rotation_deg": 0.6614151319251916, "i": 21, "j": 24 }, { "pair_index": 15, "translation_m": 0.04417889214251473, "rotation_deg": 0.537164719319421, "i": 22, "j": 23 }, { "pair_index": 16, "translation_m": 0.020100630082582033, "rotation_deg": 1.4866116021028042, "i": 22, "j": 24 }, { "pair_index": 17, "translation_m": 0.04301305432341711, "rotation_deg": 0.7052054000476768, "i": 24, "j": 26 }, { "pair_index": 18, "translation_m": 0.0344886352240195, "rotation_deg": 1.4977147244033493, "i": 27, "j": 28 }, { "pair_index": 19, "translation_m": 0.14643003383767556, "rotation_deg": 0.527768319167481, "i": 33, "j": 35 }, { "pair_index": 20, "translation_m": 0.08545677470499786, "rotation_deg": 0.7336105280022196, "i": 34, "j": 35 }, { "pair_index": 21, "translation_m": 0.025212589301108413, "rotation_deg": 1.5817598444384953, "i": 35, "j": 36 } ] } }, "separate_backend_results": { "open3d_gicp": { "translation_m": [ 1.2978831677200011, -0.0030997734098957433, 0.7217892226151688 ], "rotation_rpy_deg_xyz": [ -0.7572070226288585, 1.1460424368859559, -0.8797812288284186 ] }, "small_gicp": { "translation_m": [ 1.2996301155160686, -0.0035647011612625953, 0.7218861757826791 ], "rotation_rpy_deg_xyz": [ -0.7871563544979889, 1.1414557494228486, -0.9357571721886107 ] } }, "warning": "AX rotation RMS remains about one degree; this is not centimetre-grade absolute certification." }